A Reader’s Dating Question: In Dating do you get what you see?
Saturday, April 10th, 2010Dear Paulette,
So I was dating this guy who I met online for 2 months. In the beginning we definitely knew we liked each other a lot, and would talk on the phone and text but there was no talk on where anything was going so I continued to see other people and I assume he did as well. However, after a few weeks he asked me what I wanted out of our relationship and I told him that I was looking for something serious. He said he wanted something serious as well and was glad we were on the same page. I then asked him if he was seeing other girls and he reassured me that I was the only girl he was interested in. I immediately stopped seeing other people and focused on him. We began talking on the phone every night and he would always tell me how much he cared about me, how he hoped I wasn’t seeing other guys, how he liked how I didn’t go out that much, how he was upset I was travelling this summer and hoped I wouldn’t hook up with other guys, etc… At the time it sounded to me like he really cared about me and wanted me for himself. I told him about guys I had dated in the past who had lead me to believe I was special to them but had ultimately been with other girls and he promised me he was not one of those guys. We also decided to wait to have sex so that it would be special. When we talked and when we were together he always acted really interested in what I had to say and would even call me when out with friends. He always made me feel important and special. One weekend I was at his apartment and noticed a paper that his passwords written on it. I didn’t really think much of it at the time but the password was a common everyday word that kind of stuck. A few days after I came back from his apartment I decided that after our amazing weekend together where he told me how he was falling for me that I would delete my dating profile. While we both kept them up, I never went on mine except to check for funny messages which I would forward to him (I told him I didn’t use it for dating) and he did the same. However, I did notice that he still went on his regularly and updated it. I had asked him about what he did on it and he said he just liked to look at what kind of messages he got. So right before I was going to delete mine his password came to my mind. I have never done anything like this before, and I am not proud of what I did, but something told me to check it since it would be the last time I would be able to. I figured I would check it once and if I found nothing I would delete my profile and never think about it again. However, what I found were tons of sent messages, some of them dated the day after I left his apartment after taking a bus 3 hours to visit him where he went to college, asking girls out on dates and also telling them that he was “having trouble finding Christian girls”. I confronted him, apologizing for checking his profile but wanted to know why he lied. He basically said “we aren’t official I can do what I want”. And when I responded “So even though you tell me I can’t date other guys I really could have?” he responded “Well, as long as you didn’t tell me about it because it would have hurt me”. I know what I did was an invasion of privacy and a crazy thing to do, but my question is, did I lose a potentially really good guy or do you think he would have ended up being a cheater in the end? I know we weren’t official, but at the same time we had said we wouldn’t see other people. Is this behavior I should have to put up with or am I better off without him?
Confused
—————————-
Dear Confused,
Wow. I’m sorry that happened. Dating can be confusing and sometimes people are not what they seem. Let me start with what you did right. You were honest with him early about your intentions and told him that you wanted a serious relationship. You also decided to refrain from sleeping together until you knew each other better. I think a few things to question or think about for the future:
1. Although he said he did not want you to see other people, you could have clarified if you both are ‘officially a couple’ and therefore neither of you will be seeing other people. This does not mean that he would not cheat but it means things are crystal clear. This way you do not close down your options unnecessarily while he continues to entertain possibilities. Always ask that uncomfortable question for the sake of clarity.
2. When you decided to take down your dating profile you could have asked him to do the same. If there was resistance on his part, you could then explore why.
3. You can observe a person’s behavior and learn a lot in a short time but remember that 2 months is not a long time to know someone. Give dates time to reveal themselves over a variety of situations before fully emotionally committing to them and feeling that you really know them or what you are getting into.
4. As you said, it was not great that you checked his profile account as it compromises trust, privacy and boundaries in your relationship. It turns out that your suspicions were justified but it is a tendency that you should monitor in yourself going forward because it could be cause for someone to break up with you, should nothing be going on.
5. Trust is built in a relationship by each person doing what they say they will do (ie: their actions match their words). I am not psychic and I do not know this man but it seems to me that he did not do what he said. He said you were the only woman he was interested in and that he wanted to focus on you and then he actively searched for Christian girls. I can’t say that he would cheat in the future (although it is certainly probable) but it does seem that he is currently dishonest and was leading a sort of double life. His defense was that you were not official but it leads you to wonder if you had clarified this completely, would his actions be any different? Personally, I have my doubts.
So if I were you, I would move on. Trust is very important in a relationship and after this you would probably always be questioning what this man says. I hope you will consider the above points going forward because with every ended relationship there are lessons and possible growth. There is no way to prevent betrayal and hurt while dating, no matter how wonderful you are. Sometimes you will come across dishonest people. All you can do is try to make things clear, honor your words and watch to see if the other person does the same. If they do, you can move forward together and build your relationship. If there is no trust or clear communication you will eventually end up apart.My Best in Love,
Paulette
Author of ‘Dating from the Inside Out: How to Use the Law of Attraction in Matters of the Heart’ published by Atria Books.







